The toll argument usually goes one of two ways. Operations says the motorway is faster, so take it. Finance sees a toll line on the invoice, and says take the free road.
Both are arguing about the toll. Neither has asked what the saved time is worth. That is the whole decision, and it can be done on one line of arithmetic.
The break-even sum
A toll buys minutes. So the test is:
Toll in baht Γ· cost of one vehicle-minute = minutes the toll must save.
If the motorway saves more minutes than that, and the minutes get used, the toll pays for itself. If not, it is a cost with nothing behind it.
The cost of a vehicle-minute has two parts:
- The driver. All in, a driver on a 21,000 baht salary costs about 112 baht an hour over the normal working day, as worked out here. That is the floor.
- The truck. Its standing costs (instalments or depreciation, insurance, licence) are paid for the day whether it moves or not, so an hour saved is an hour of the truck's day. Use your own figure, or the carrier's.
A worked example (an illustration)
A ten-wheel truck on Motorway 9 between Bang Pa-in and Bang Phli passes two toll plazas. Each is 70 baht for a vehicle of more than six wheels, so 140 baht one way. That toll is from the Department of Highways table.
The rest is assumed, to show the method:
- The free road is 50 minutes slower one way
- The truck's standing cost works out at 200 baht an hour
| Per hour | Minutes the 140 baht toll must save | |
|---|---|---|
| Driver alone | 112 | 75 |
| Driver plus truck | 312 | 27 |
On those numbers, 50 minutes saved is worth about 260 baht, against a toll of 140. The toll pays by about 120 baht a trip.
Change one assumption and the answer changes. If the free road is only 20 minutes slower, the toll loses. Run your own lane with your own figures. The point is the shape of the sum, not these numbers.
The catch: saved time is worth money only if it is used
This is where most toll decisions go wrong. A saved hour is worth 312 baht only if something is done with it. Check which of these is true:
- It frees a trip. The truck makes one more run in the day, or one fewer truck is needed for the schedule.
- It saves a stretch of overtime, or keeps the driver inside the legal day.
- It meets a window or a cut-off. A dock slot, or a vessel cut-off, where being late costs far more than the toll. The Ayutthaya to Laem Chabang run is built backwards from that cut-off.
- It buys certainty. A road whose time barely changes lets you promise a time you can keep.
If none is true, the truck arrives early, waits at the gate, and the toll bought nothing. Then take the free road, however slow.
The driver's legal day can decide it for you
Section 103 bis of the Land Transport Act, read in Thai, limits a driver to four consecutive hours of driving, then a rest of at least half an hour before a further stretch of up to four. A slow road eats into those hours. On a long lane, a leg that fits inside one stretch on the motorway may need an extra stop on the free road. That can turn a one-day job into a two-day job. See one driver or two on a long run for how that sum goes.
Fix it before the truck leaves, not on the invoice
Tolls are the line nobody settles in advance, so they get argued after the trip. Three things to agree at booking:
- Which road the price assumes. A quote built on the motorway is not comparable with one built on the free road.
- Whether tolls are in the rate or passed through at cost. If at cost, ask for the plaza receipts, and expect the claimed toll to match the road agreed.
- Who may change the route. A driver who takes the free road to save a toll, and arrives late, has made a decision that belongs to you.
When the invoice comes, check the toll line against the job record like any other line.
What to do on Monday
- Pick your three busiest lanes. For each, write down the toll for your truck class one way, from the Department of Highways table.
- Find out what the free road costs in minutes on a normal day and on a bad one. Ask the dispatcher, or read it off the tracking record.
- Divide the toll by your cost per vehicle-minute. That is the minutes to beat.
- Ask whether the minutes saved are actually used. If not, the free road wins on that lane.
- Write the answer into the booking: which road, and who pays the toll.
Where the evidence stops: no Thai study measuring toll road against free road time for trucks was found, so the 50 minute gap and the 200 baht truck hour are assumptions, not data. The Motorway 9 tolls were read from the Department of Highways table image. The Motorway 7 amounts depend on the pair of plazas used and were not worked out here. Fuel was left out of the sum, because no Thai figure was found for the extra fuel burned in stop-start traffic on the free road. Section 103 bis was read in Thai for an earlier article on this site and was not read again today.
