The invoice arrives. Accounts payable checks the total against the rate card, the sums are right, and it is paid.
Nothing in that check looked at whether the truck came. A bill can add up perfectly and still charge you for a job you never ordered, a job billed twice, a bigger truck than the one that turned up, or a waiting charge nobody agreed. The arithmetic is only the last of the things that can be wrong.
This article is about a check that takes about an hour a month and catches the rest. It is separate from the tax side of the bill, which another article on this site covers: the receipt, the withholding rate and the lines that change the tax on each other. This one is about whether the bill is right, not whether it is lawful.
Three records, one invoice
Every line on a carrier's invoice makes three claims at once. Each claim has a record you already hold, or should.
| The invoice line says | The record that confirms it | Where it lives |
|---|---|---|
| This job happened, on this date, on this lane | Your job record: the booking you made, with date, lane, truck type and the number you gave the carrier | Your booking sheet or system |
| It was delivered | The proof of delivery: the signed delivery note, with arrival time and any damage written on it | Your receiving point or the carrier's copy |
| At this price | The rate agreement: rate by lane and truck type, and the rules for any extra charge | Your contract or quote confirmation |
A line passes only when all three agree. If the job record has no such booking, the line fails. If there is a booking but no signed delivery note, the line waits. If both exist but the price is not what the agreement says for that lane and truck, the line is wrong by the difference.
What goes wrong, in the order it usually shows up
- A job you have no record of. A load another department booked, a trip cancelled after the invoice run began, or a mistake. Check the job record first, because everything else depends on it.
- The same job twice. Often a re-issued invoice, or a job split across two billing periods. Sort the invoice by date, lane and truck and look for repeats.
- The wrong price tier. You booked a 6-wheel truck, a 10-wheel arrived, and the carrier billed the 10-wheel rate. Whether you should pay for a bigger truck you did not ask for is a question for the booking terms. The invoice should not decide it quietly.
- An extra charge nobody agreed. Waiting time past free time, urgency, a toll, a fuel surcharge. Each has a rule in your agreement, or should. The waiting charge article shows how to set free time from your own gate records, which is what lets you test a waiting line instead of arguing about it.
- Money paid out for you. Tolls and fees the carrier paid and passed on. Ask for the receipts. The law treats these as part of what the carrier may claim, so they are legitimate, but they are also the line most likely to arrive as one lump with no detail.
- A damaged or short delivery. The delivery note says so, the invoice charges in full. Keep this apart from the price check, and see below.
An illustration, with made-up numbers
The numbers here show the method. They are not Thai market rates.
Suppose you agreed 4,200 baht for a 6-wheel truck and 6,800 baht for a 10-wheel truck on one lane. In the month you ordered 20 six-wheel jobs and 11 ten-wheel jobs.
- The correct bill for 31 jobs is 20 Γ 4,200 + 11 Γ 6,800 = 84,000 + 74,800 = 158,800 baht.
- The invoice arrives with 33 lines. It contains the 31 real jobs, one of them repeated (+4,200), one 6-wheel job charged at the 10-wheel rate (+2,600), and a waiting charge of 1,500 that your agreement does not allow at the time recorded.
- It totals 158,800 + 4,200 + 2,600 + 1,500 = 167,100 baht. Every sum on it is correct.
The excess is 8,300 baht, or 8,300 Γ· 167,100 = 5.0% of the invoice. At 33 lines and about two minutes a line, the check takes 66 minutes. If every month looked like this, 12 Γ 8,300 = 99,600 baht would leave the business in a year, found by one hour a month.
Your own error rate will differ, and could be nothing. That is the point of measuring it: you do not know until you count.
The stronger version: price the month before the invoice arrives
Checking an invoice line by line against records is the weak form, because it starts from the carrier's list. The stronger form starts from yours.
At month end, before the invoice is due, work out what you expect to owe from your job record alone: each job, priced from the rate agreement. That is your own bill. When the invoice arrives, the only work is comparing two totals and then chasing the difference line by line. A job you booked but is missing from the invoice shows up too, which the line-by-line check cannot see.
Two limits. This needs a job record kept as the day goes, not rebuilt at month end, so it depends on whatever your team already writes down about each booking. And it needs the agreement to be clear enough to price from; where a rule is vague, expect disputes.
How much checking is enough
Check every line for the first three months of a carrier. That gives you an error rate and the kinds of error that carrier makes. After that, a sample can be enough when the rate is low. Where the line sits, such as "under 1% of value for three months running", is a judgement for you to set. No Thai figure was found for what is normal. If the rate stays above your limit, go back to full checks and take the pattern to the carrier at the next review.
Count the errors by type and by carrier. A carrier whose mistakes are all duplicates has a billing-system problem. A carrier whose mistakes are all in its own favour on extras has a different one.
Disputing a line without starting a fight
- Pay what is not in dispute, on time, and name the disputed lines in writing with the reason and the record: "no booking on that date", "delivery note shows a 6-wheel truck". Ask for a credit note.
- Do not quietly deduct. Taking money off a bill because you think you are owed damages sets a damage claim against a freight claim and invites the same treatment back. The damaged goods article covers why withholding freight backfires; the short version is to run the damage claim on its own track.
- Send the dispute fast. Your records are freshest the week after the job.
The law gives the carrier two years, and a part payment resets them
Three sections of the Civil and Commercial Code, read in Thai, decide how long an unsettled bill stays alive.
- Section 193/34(3). A carrier's claim for freight, rent and fees, and for money it paid out for you, has a limitation of two years.
- Section 193/12. The two years start from when the claim could first be enforced, not from when you noticed it.
- Sections 193/14(1) and 193/15. If the debtor acknowledges the debt in writing, pays part of it, pays interest, or does anything that clearly shows it accepts the debt, the time already run does not count and a fresh two years starts.
Two things follow, and neither needs a lawyer to act on.
- A late bill is still a good bill. A carrier that finds an unbilled job from a year ago may still claim it. If your month-end figure leaves out jobs not yet invoiced, your costs are understated. Ask in the agreement for invoices within a set number of days of delivery, and estimate the unbilled jobs from your own job record in the meantime.
- A part payment of a disputed bill can restart the clock. Paying the undisputed part and marking the rest as disputed is still the right course. Just do not assume that silence runs the clock down for you.
What to do on Monday
- Pick one carrier and one recent invoice. Print the invoice and your job record for the month.
- Mark each invoice line against the job record, then the delivery note, then the rate agreement.
- Count lines that fail and add up the baht. That is your first error rate.
- Write down the three or four rules that would have settled each failure, such as a free-time rule or a time limit for invoicing, and add them at the next contract review.
- Next month, price the jobs yourself before the invoice arrives.
Where the evidence stops: no Thai study of billing errors in road freight was found, and the textbook treats invoice accuracy as a quality measure rather than describing how to audit a carrier's bill. The three-record test and the monthly self-pricing step are standard accounts-payable practice, offered as method. The 5.0% error rate, the two-minute line check and the rates in the example are an illustration. The limitation sections were read in Thai on one host only. The limitation period for a shipper's own claim to recover an overpayment was not looked up.
